ABSTRACT
The increasing reliance on plant-derived
substances for fishing practices, particularly in tropical regions, raises
significant concerns regarding their ecological impacts and toxicity to aquatic
organisms. This study investigated the effects of two widely used ichthyotoxic
plants Luffa cylindrica and Tetrapleura tetraptera on the embryonic development
and hatching success ofthe Clarias gariepinus. The primary objective was to
evaluate the acute toxicity ofthe plant extracts, their influence on water
quality and associated oxidative stress levels in the fish embryos. To achieve
the objective of this study, series of controlled hatchery and laboratory
experiments were conducted over one year period at Michael Okpara University of
Agriculture and Akwa Ibom State University. The experiments involved collection
and preparation of mature fresh leaves from both plant species and
determination of their bioactive constituents. Their aqueous extracts were
subjected to bioassays to determine their lethal concentrations (LC50) and
impacts on developmental stages ofthe fish. Physico-chemical parameters ofwater
media used for the experiment, including temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen, ammonia,
alkalinity, biological oxygen demand (BOD5), total dissolved solids (TDS) and
total hardness were monitored throughout this period for 96- hours. Data was
collected from laboratory analyses of water quality parameters, phytochemical
screening, assessment of fish health through oxidative stress responses,
embryogenesis and hatching success of the fish early stages, while data on
haematological, histopathological, length-weight and body condition index
evaluations were obtained in the grow out stage. Results revealed that both
herbs impacted the physico-chemical characteristics of the water, with the
highest concentration (70 ml/1) leading to decreased dissolved oxygen levels
(3.01, 2.97 mg/1) and increased ammonia (0.04, 0.03 mg/1) concentrations for L.
cylindrica and T. tetraptera, respectively. Acute toxicity tests indicated
that!. cylindrica had a lower LC50 value (169.25 ml/1) compared to T.
tetraptera (190.66 ml/1), suggesting a higher toxicity level, particularly at
elevated concentrations. This study also reported that exposure to these plant
extracts adversely impacted fertilization rate, hatching success and overall
developmental stages ofthe fish. Hatching success was higher in control groups
compared to those exposed to the extracts, with lower concentrations yielding
better outcomes. Protective enzymes, superoxide dismutase (SOD) and
glutathiones-transferase (GST) indicated a strong response to oxidative stress,
with elevated SOD levels correlating with increased mortality rates. The study
also revealed variations in haematological and histopathological
characteristics of grow-out fish with length-weight relationslup showing
negative allometry while body wellbeing remained poor. This study highlights
the potential risks associated with the indiscriminate use of both plant
extracts in capture fisheries, emphasizing the need for careful management of
these herbicides to the'Sn,Seir adverse effects on the a9uatic ecosystems and
fish. The study also underscores devehnmen1;? H UnderStanding to™ological
impacts of plant extracts on fish health and for fXr d r.eC°"lmends a “ban
on t
ASUQUO (2026). Ecotoxicological Assessment of Widely Used Herbal Piscicides in Nigerian Capture Fisheries: A Case Study on Clarias gariepinus:- Asuquo, Idopiseabasi E. Mouau.afribary.org: Retrieved Apr 15, 2026, from https://repository.mouau.edu.ng/work/view/ecotoxicological-assessment-of-widely-used-herbal-piscicides-in-nigerian-capture-fisheries-a-case-study-on-clarias-gariepinus-asuquo-idopiseabasi-e-7-2
ASUQUO. "Ecotoxicological Assessment of Widely Used Herbal Piscicides in Nigerian Capture Fisheries: A Case Study on Clarias gariepinus:- Asuquo, Idopiseabasi E" Mouau.afribary.org. Mouau.afribary.org, 15 Apr. 2026, https://repository.mouau.edu.ng/work/view/ecotoxicological-assessment-of-widely-used-herbal-piscicides-in-nigerian-capture-fisheries-a-case-study-on-clarias-gariepinus-asuquo-idopiseabasi-e-7-2. Accessed 15 Apr. 2026.
ASUQUO. "Ecotoxicological Assessment of Widely Used Herbal Piscicides in Nigerian Capture Fisheries: A Case Study on Clarias gariepinus:- Asuquo, Idopiseabasi E". Mouau.afribary.org, Mouau.afribary.org, 15 Apr. 2026. Web. 15 Apr. 2026. < https://repository.mouau.edu.ng/work/view/ecotoxicological-assessment-of-widely-used-herbal-piscicides-in-nigerian-capture-fisheries-a-case-study-on-clarias-gariepinus-asuquo-idopiseabasi-e-7-2 >.
ASUQUO. "Ecotoxicological Assessment of Widely Used Herbal Piscicides in Nigerian Capture Fisheries: A Case Study on Clarias gariepinus:- Asuquo, Idopiseabasi E" Mouau.afribary.org (2026). Accessed 15 Apr. 2026. https://repository.mouau.edu.ng/work/view/ecotoxicological-assessment-of-widely-used-herbal-piscicides-in-nigerian-capture-fisheries-a-case-study-on-clarias-gariepinus-asuquo-idopiseabasi-e-7-2